My Father The Judge Cigars
MY FATHER THE JUDGE
MY FATHER THE JUDGE
Across the line, The Judge is known for dense smoke, firm structure, and a flavor profile that commonly moves through spice, cocoa, coffee, wood, and leather. Its identity is also tied to one of the line’s most important distinctions: the Grand Robusto earned 98 points and was named Cigar Aficionado’s Cigar of the Year in 2017, a result that helped establish My Father The Judge as one of the most recognized modern releases in the broader My Father portfolio.
...Read More
-
Rating100%My Father The Judge Grand RobustoGreat CigarHighly recommend this cigar for anyone, the beginning smoker to the seasoned veteran. Great flavor and a nice size. One of the staples to my humidor.
By ChrisF94RT
on
Verified Buyer
-
Rating100%My Father The Judge Toro FinoJudge- Toro FinoKeep coming back to this, We’ll constructed, even burn and delicious at all times. You feel like a judge when you smoke them :) thank you
By Murat S.
on
Verified Buyer
-
Rating100%My Father The Judge Toro FinoLives up to the hypeLove My Father, size-ring matters not. Excellent craftsmanship, beautiful wrapper. Great cigar.
By Jumper57
on
Verified Buyer
-
Rating100%My Father The Judge ToroFantastic CigarFantastic cigar for any stage of smoker. Bold, yet smooth flavors mixed with an even burn. Just such a delight, would highly recommend.
By Brian
on
Verified Buyer
-
Rating80%My Father The Judge ToroSmooth and BoldA very good and enjoyable cigar that is full of aroma.
By Sal
on
Verified Buyer
-
Rating100%My Father The Judge Toro FinoLove themThis is first impression and experience of my father's cigars, i ordered the judge because of their high rating and strong favor. It did not disappoint i really enjoyed the cigars!
By Slydogg
on
Verified Buyer
-
Rating100%My Father The Judge Corona GordaGreat SmokeOne of the best cigars i have smoked.
By MH
on
Verified Buyer
-
Rating100%My Father The Judge Toro FinoThe JudgeEver since I discovered My Father cigars I've kept them stocked in my humidor and The Judge is another great smoke to add to the list.
By Hillbilly
on
Verified Buyer
-
Rating100%My Father The Judge Corona GordaThe best!I have smoked a bunch of different cigars and this one is the best! Always an easy smooth draw with every cigar. Each cigar is handmade to perfection.
By D
on
Verified Buyer
-
Rating100%My Father The Judge Corona GordaThis may be the best cigar I've smoked in 52 years of smoking cigarsI wrote a review on 4/5/25 after buying a five-pack and smoking one. I have since finished the five-pack, and I did end up ordering a box. I had one cigar in the first five with some construction issues, unraveling a bit, but not badly enough to prevent smoking it. The other four had zero problems, so I ordered a box. I have been smoking cigars for 52 years, and I'm pretty sure this is the best cigar I've ever smoked. Of course I smoked a lot of bad cigars as a young man, but top shelf cigars for at least the last 25 years.
By Joe
on
Verified Buyer
-
Rating100%My Father The Judge Toro FinoLove themThis is first impression and experience of my father's cigars, i ordered the judge because of their high rating and strong favor. It did not disappoint i really enjoyed the cigars!
By Slydogg
on
Verified Buyer
-
Rating100%My Father The Judge ToroMy Father's The Judge Toro is a cigar that exudes power and refinementMy Father's The Judge Toro is an outstanding cigar that commands attention with its bold flavor and impeccable construction. This full-bodied cigar features a dark and oily Ecuadorian Sumatra wrapper. Upon lighting, the flavors come alive with an impressive complexity. Notes of dark cocoa, black pepper, and hints of leather intertwine on the palate, creating a robust and satisfying profile. The construction is flawless, offering an effortless draw and a razor-sharp burn that enhances the smoking experience. My Father's The Judge Toro is a cigar that exudes power and refinement, making it an exceptional choice that leaves a lasting impression.
By JC-Harvey
on
Verified Buyer
-
Rating100%My Father The Judge ToroDeliciously BoldThis stick had a perfect burn & construction with a bold nutty flavor. I recommend giving it a try!
By dylan
on
Verified Buyer
-
Rating100%My Father The Judge Grand RobustoStrong and LongA great strong flavored cigar with a nice even burn which lasts long enough for some great conversations.
By JPSPLICER
on
-
Rating100%My Father The Judge Corona GordaOh MY Father!!!This stick is delicious and I can't that about a lot. This was gifted by a friend. After smoking it I order more.
By SW Smoker
on
-
Rating80%My Father The Judge ToroOutstanding cigarOutstanding cigar from start to finish.
By Javier Gautier
on
-
Rating100%My Father The Judge Grand RobustoMy Father the Judge and the GreatWell done Cigar, perfect quality full Of flavor, a must try cigar
By Samy Ben Salem
on
- Wrapper Connecticut Remove This Item
- Shape Petite Robusto Remove This Item
- Binder Honduras Remove This Item