Luxury Cigar Lounge Still Life
|

What to Buy a Cigar Smoker (When You Don’t Smoke Cigars Yourself)

Gift Guide

You are buying for someone who knows far more about this than you do. That is the whole problem, and it is a completely solvable one.

Most people buying cigars in December do not smoke cigars. You are a wife, a husband, a daughter, a coworker who drew their name. You are standing in front of a wall of boxes with no idea whether the person you love prefers something mild or something that could strip paint, and the internet keeps showing you lists written for people who already know.

This guide is written for you instead. We have been selling cigars since 1950 and we have this conversation in the shop every single day in December. Here is what we actually tell people.

The 30-second answer
  • If you know nothing at all: a sampler. Several different cigars in one box, so they find something they like and you cannot pick wrong.
  • If you want to spend under $30: five cigars from our Flagship sampler, or a good torch lighter at $13.50.
  • If you want it to feel generous: a 20-cigar sampler, around $97–$164.
  • If you are genuinely stuck: a gift card. No shame in it. More on that below.

The one thing that makes this easy

You do not need to know what they smoke. You only need to avoid betting the whole gift on a guess.

A box of 25 identical cigars is a bet. If you guess their taste wrong, they are stuck with 25 of something they do not enjoy, and they will be very gracious about it, and they will not smoke them. A sampler is the opposite: five or ten different cigars, so the odds of at least a few being a hit are excellent. It also tells you what to buy next year, because they will mention the one they liked.

This is why nearly every recommendation below is a sampler or an accessory. Both sidestep the taste problem entirely.

Three samplers, any budget

Each of these comes in four sizes, so the same safe choice works whether you are spending $29 or $390. Pick the cigar first, then the size that fits your budget.

Our Flagship Cigar Sampler from Mike’s Cigars
Best for a first gift

Our Flagship Cigar Sampler

Rated 100% by our customers · Licenciados, Buzz, Fonseca, Mike’s 1950 and 898 Collection · medium bodied

Medium-bodied and genuinely crowd-pleasing, which is exactly what you want when you are guessing. Nothing here is challenging, and the five brands span enough ground that they will find a favourite.

SizePrice
5 cigars$28.95
10 cigars$50.95
20 cigars$96.95
50 cigars$229.95
Shop the Flagship Sampler
95+ Rated Cigar of the Year Sampler
Best for a serious smoker

95-Rated Cigar of the Year Sampler

Rated 98% by our customers over 11 reviews · Alec Bradley Prensado, My Father Le Bijou 1922, Flor de las Antillas, Perez Carrillo and Flathead 554

Every cigar in this one scored 95 or higher with the major reviewers. If the person you are buying for takes cigars seriously, this is the gift that signals you did your homework — even though all you did was read this sentence.

SizePriceMSRP
5 cigars$47.95$54.40
10 cigars$85.95$108.80
20 cigars$163.95$217.60
50 cigars$389.95$544.00
Shop the 95-Rated Sampler
Oliva Serie V Variety Sampler box of five
Best single brand

Oliva Serie V Variety Sampler

Rated 100% by our customers over 7 reviews · five Serie V vitolas, full bodied

One brand rather than a mix, and a very good one. Oliva’s Serie V has taken Cigar of the Year honours and is a name a cigar smoker recognises immediately. Choose this over a mixed sampler if you already know they like full-bodied cigars.

SizePriceMSRP
Box of 5$65.50$76.50
Shop the Oliva Serie V Sampler
Your budgetWhat to get
Under $30Flagship Sampler, 5 cigars — $28.95
$30 to $7095-Rated Sampler, 5 cigars — $47.95, or the Oliva Serie V — $65.50
$70 to $10095-Rated Sampler, 10 cigars — $85.95, or Flagship 20 — $96.95
$100 to $20095-Rated Sampler, 20 cigars — $163.95
$200 and upFlagship 50 — $229.95, or 95-Rated 50 — $389.95

The accessory shortcut

Accessories remove the taste problem completely. You cannot buy the wrong flavour of lighter. And most cigar smokers are quietly using a cheap cutter they have had for years, because they spend their money on cigars rather than tools.

One caution on humidors: a humidor is a wonderful gift for someone who does not have one, and an awkward one for someone who does. If you are not sure whether they own one, buy cigars instead. If you do buy a humidor, it needs humidification and about two weeks of seasoning before it holds cigars properly, so give it early or explain that part.

What not to buy

The five mistakes we see every December

  • Guessing on flavored cigars. Vanilla, rum and sweet-tipped cigars have devoted fans and we stock more than 200 of them, but they are a question of taste rather than a safe default. If you know they enjoy flavored cigars, that is a lovely gift. If you are guessing, stay traditional.
  • Anything from a gas station or a drugstore. Those are machine-made with homogenised tobacco. Handing one to someone who smokes premium cigars is like giving a wine drinker cooking sherry.
  • A full box of 25 of one cigar you picked yourself. Covered above. Too big a bet on a guess.
  • A cigar because the band looks impressive. Packaging and quality are unrelated, and the showiest boxes are often the worst value.
  • Cuban cigars from a holiday or a website. They cannot legally be sold in the United States, and the overwhelming majority sold to tourists are counterfeit. You are risking money on a fake and putting them in an awkward position.

How to find out what they smoke without spoiling the surprise

If you want to buy actual cigars rather than a sampler, you need one piece of information: what they smoke now. Three ways to get it without asking directly.

  • Photograph a band. The paper ring around the cigar carries the brand. Take a picture of one in their ashtray or humidor and send it to us — we will tell you what it is and what else they would like.
  • Look in their humidor. If several cigars look the same, that is their regular. If the box is dark and oily looking, they lean toward maduro and fuller flavours.
  • Ask their shop. If they buy locally, the shop knows their order. If they buy from us, call (800) 962-4427 and we can look it up.

The two gifts you genuinely cannot get wrong

Mike’s Cigars gift card

A gift card

There is a snobbery about gift cards that does not apply here. Cigars are intensely personal, choosing them is half the pleasure, and handing someone the ability to pick exactly what they want is not lazy — it is accurate. Pair it with a $13.50 lighter so there is something to unwrap and you have a complete gift.

Shop Gift Cards

The Cigar of the Month Club

Five super-premium cigars of their choosing arrive every month, plus a luxury accessory, and members get free ground shipping on everything they order for the length of the membership. Silver, Gold and Platinum memberships include a humidor with the first shipment, which solves two gifts at once.

Memberships run $125 for three months, $225 for six, $410 for a year and $575 for eighteen. The longer terms work out to roughly a third less per month, and the gift keeps arriving long after December.

Shop the Cigar of the Month Club

Frequently asked questions

How many cigars is a good gift?

Five is a real gift. Ten feels generous. Twenty is a significant present. One single cigar is a nice gesture alongside something else, but it is thin on its own.

Do cigars go bad if they sit under the tree?

A few weeks in normal room conditions will not ruin them, though they will dry slightly. If you are buying in November for December, leave them in the sealed packaging and keep them away from radiators and sunny windowsills.

What does “mild” or “full-bodied” actually mean?

Roughly how much the cigar makes itself felt. Mild is gentle and easy; full-bodied is strong, rich and can be overwhelming on an empty stomach. If you do not know which they prefer, mild to medium is the safer guess — a strong smoker will still enjoy a mild cigar, but the reverse is often not true.

Can I have it shipped directly to them as a surprise?

Yes. We ship across the United States and an adult signature is required on delivery, so someone needs to be home. If it is going to a workplace, make sure that is allowed first.

What if they already have everything?

Then buy consumables rather than objects. Nobody has too many cigars, and nobody turns down humidification supplies, which quietly run out and rarely get replaced on time.

The bottom line

You are not expected to understand cigars. You are expected to show that you paid attention to someone, and a well-chosen sampler with a decent lighter does that better than an expensive box of something they will never smoke.

If you are still unsure, call us on (800) 962-4427 and describe the person. We do this every day in December, and we would rather spend five minutes on the phone than have you guess.

Still not sure? Start with a sampler.

Several cigars, one box, no wrong answer.

Shop Cigar Samplers

Similar Posts